When to Run a Nanny Background Check, Plus State Rules Every Family Should Know

Nanny carrying a young girl on her shoulders in a park

Hiring a nanny is one of the biggest decisions a family makes. You are trusting someone with your children, your home and your daily routine. A background check is one of the best tools you have to make that decision with confidence.

Many parents, though, are unsure when to run one, what the law requires, and whether the rules change depending on where they live. One rule applies everywhere: do not let a nanny start until the background check comes back.

When Should You Run a Nanny Background Check?

The best time to run a nanny background check is after you have chosen your top candidate and made a conditional job offer, and the candidate has accepted it. A conditional offer means the job is yours as long as the background check comes back in a way you can accept.

This timing works well for several reasons:

  • It follows fair chance laws. A growing number of states and cities require employers to wait until after a conditional offer before looking at criminal history. Following this order from the start keeps you on the right side of those rules.
  • It saves you money. Background checks cost money for each person. Running one on your final choice, rather than on every applicant, keeps your costs down.
  • It respects the candidate. People are more willing to share personal details, like a Social Security number and date of birth, once they know they have an offer.
  • It keeps you focused on fit first. Interviews and reference calls tell you whether someone is right for your family. The background check then confirms there is nothing in their history that rules them out.

States and cities that set the timing for you

In some places, waiting until after a conditional offer is the law and not just good practice. Certain cities and states have specific requirements on when the background check can be run.

State or cityWho must follow itEarliest point you can ask about or check criminal history
HawaiiAll private employersAfter a conditional job offer
Philadelphia, PAEmployers with one or more employees in the cityAfter a conditional job offer
New York CityEmployers in the city, with domestic workers protected under the city’s Human Rights LawAfter a conditional job offer
California (plus Los Angeles County and San Francisco)Employers with five or more employeesAfter a conditional job offer
WashingtonAll employers, with an exception for jobs with unsupervised access to childrenAfter the candidate is found otherwise qualified
MinnesotaAll private employersAfter the candidate is selected for an interview, or after a conditional offer
Chicago, ILAll employers in the cityAfter the candidate is selected for an interview, or after a conditional offer
ColoradoAll private employersNot on the initial job application
ConnecticutAll employersNot on the initial job application
Illinois (statewide)Employers with 15 or more employeesAfter the candidate is selected for an interview, or after a conditional offer
New JerseyEmployers with 15 or more employees, not counting domestic workersAfter the first interview

If you live in one of these places, running the check after a written conditional offer keeps you in line with the law. If you live somewhere else, the same order is still the safest habit.

Here is what a typical hiring order looks like:

  1. Post the job and screen applicants for experience and availability.
  2. Interview your top candidates and check references.
  3. Make a conditional offer in writing.
  4. Give the candidate a written disclosure and get their signed authorization.
  5. Run the background check.
  6. Review the results and make your final decision.
  7. Once the check has cleared, schedule a paid trial day or the first day of work.

Put the conditional nature of the offer in writing. A simple sentence works: “This offer is contingent on a background check that is satisfactory to our family.” It sets clear expectations and protects you if the results raise a concern.

Most importantly, a candidate should not spend time with your children until the background check has cleared. That includes trial days, working interviews and short babysitting shifts. Interviews can happen with your children nearby, but any hands-on care should wait until you have reviewed the results and made your final decision.

It can be tempting to let a nanny start early, especially when you need help right away. But if something concerning shows up after they have already started, you are left in an uncomfortable spot. You may have to let go of someone your children are getting attached to, have a hard conversation in your own home, and start your search over. Most Sure Check reports come back within 8 hours, so waiting for the results is far easier than undoing a hire.

Smiling nanny holding a baby at home after passing a nanny background check

What about working interviews and trial days?

A working interview is hands-on care, even if you are home the whole time. That means it belongs after the conditional offer and the cleared background check, not before.

Many parents worry that asking for a background check early will scare off a good candidate. The fix is the order: interview, check references, make a conditional offer, run the check, then schedule the paid trial. Most Sure Check reports come back within 8 hours, so this order rarely slows your search down. In places like New York City, Philadelphia and California, you cannot run the check before an offer anyway.

This order also protects you from paying for a trial with a candidate you cannot hire. If the driving record or criminal search raises a concern, you learn it before your baby spends a single hour with them.

What Federal Law Requires of Every Family

When you use a background check company to screen a nanny, you become an employer using a consumer report. That means the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, or FCRA, applies to you. It does not matter that you are a family and not a business. The Federal Trade Commission explains these duties in plain language.

Under the FCRA, you must:

  • Give a written disclosure. Tell the candidate in writing that you will get a background report for employment purposes. This notice must be its own document, separate from the job offer or other paperwork.
  • Get written permission. The candidate must sign an authorization before you order the check.
  • Send a pre-adverse action notice if you might say no. If something in the report could lead you to withdraw the offer, you must first send the candidate a copy of the report and a document called “A Summary of Your Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act.”
  • Wait before deciding. Give the candidate a fair chance to explain or correct the record. Five business days is the common practice.
  • Send a final adverse action notice. If you decide not to hire, you must tell the candidate, give the name and contact details of the background check company, and explain their right to dispute the report.

These steps are all included in Sure Check’s processes.

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission also reminds employers to apply the same standards to every candidate. A good screening company will provide the disclosure, authorization and adverse action forms for you, so you do not have to draft them yourself.

Why State Rules Matter for Families

Federal law sets the floor. States and cities can add more rules on top. For nanny hiring, two types of state laws come up most often.

Fair chance or “ban-the-box” laws control when an employer can ask about criminal history and how they can use it. Many of these laws only apply to employers with a certain number of workers, such as 5 or 15 employees. A family with one nanny often falls below that number. However, some laws cover every employer no matter the size, and some cities have special rules for domestic workers.

Cannabis protection laws limit how employers can treat a person’s legal, off-duty marijuana use. These matter if you plan to include a drug test.

Even when a law does not technically apply to your household, following its basic steps is a smart habit. Waiting until after a conditional offer, looking only at records that relate to the job, and giving the candidate a chance to explain are all fair practices that protect your family too.

What Are Ban-the-Box Rules?

Ban-the-box laws get their name from the checkbox on job applications that asked, “Have you ever been convicted of a crime?” These laws remove that question from the application and push any criminal history questions to later in the hiring process. The idea is to let employers judge a candidate on their skills and experience first.

Hawaii passed the first ban-the-box law in 1998. Today many states have one, but most only cover government jobs. A smaller group, including California, Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Minnesota, New Jersey, Oregon and Washington, also covers private employers.

When the law lets you ask

Ban-the-box laws fall into three general groups:

  1. Not on the application. Colorado and Connecticut only bar criminal history questions on the initial job application.
  2. After the interview. Illinois, Minnesota and New Jersey let employers ask once a candidate has been selected for an interview or has had a first interview.
  3. After a conditional offer. Hawaii, California, New York City and Philadelphia make employers wait until a conditional job offer before asking or running a criminal background check.

Does ban the box apply to my family?

It depends on where you live and how many people you employ. Some laws, like those in Illinois and New Jersey, only cover employers with 15 or more workers. Others, like Hawaii, Minnesota, Colorado, Connecticut, Philadelphia and Chicago, cover employers of any size. New York City protects domestic workers directly.

What ban the box does not do

Ban-the-box laws do not stop you from running a background check on a nanny. They control when you ask and, in many places, how you decide. Some cities also require you to look at the record individually, give the candidate the report and a chance to respond, and explain your decision in writing.

Posting in nanny Facebook groups

Many families find nannies through local Facebook groups, Nextdoor or parent group chats. A post in one of these groups is still a job ad, and the same rules apply to it.

  • Leave criminal history out of the post. Lines like “no criminal record” or “must have a clean background” can break fair chance rules in some places. Colorado, for example, bars employers from stating in a job ad that people with criminal records cannot apply.
  • Be careful with “background check required.” In New York City, employers cannot say a background check is required in a job ad before a conditional offer. A safer line is “Final candidate will complete a background check after an offer.” Outside New York City, that line is fine in most places.

The simplest approach is to keep your post about the job: the schedule, the ages of your children, the pay and the duties. Save the background check for after you make an offer.

Found a great candidate in a group? See How do I run a background check on a nanny I found on Facebook? in the FAQ below.

Simple ways to stay on the safe side

  • Leave criminal history questions off your job post and application.
  • In New York City, do not write “background check required” in your job ad.
  • Wait until after a written conditional offer to run the criminal background check.
  • Judge any record on whether it relates to caring for children, how long ago it happened and what the person has done since.

Most of these steps match the FCRA process above, so following them takes little extra effort.

State Rules at a Glance

The table below summarizes how fair chance and cannabis rules work in thirteen of the highest-volume hiring states.

StateFair chance rulesCannabis protections
CaliforniaPublic and private employersLawful off-duty use protected
FloridaNone statewideNone
GeorgiaPublic employers onlyNone
IllinoisPublic and private employersLawful off-duty use protected
MichiganPublic employers onlyLimited (off-duty use, government jobs)
New JerseyPublic and private employersLawful off-duty use protected
New YorkPublic and private employersLawful off-duty use protected
North CarolinaPublic employers onlyNone
OhioPublic employers onlyNone
PennsylvaniaPublic employers onlyNone
TexasPublic employers onlyNone
VirginiaPublic and private employersLawful-use protections
WashingtonPublic and private employersPre-employment testing limits

Here is what the most important of these rules mean for a family hiring a nanny.

California

California’s Fair Chance Act applies to employers with five or more employees. It bars covered employers from asking about conviction history before a conditional offer and requires an individual review of any record before saying no. Los Angeles County and San Francisco have their own ordinances with similar size limits. Most families with one nanny fall below the threshold, but many households with several staff do not.

California also protects off-duty cannabis use under a law known as AB 2188, which took effect in 2024. Covered employers generally cannot reject someone for legal use away from work or for a drug test that only shows non-impairing cannabis traces.

California limits how far back background check companies can report most convictions, usually seven years. Families can also ask whether a nanny is listed on TrustLine, the state’s registry of in-home child care providers who have passed a fingerprint check. Nannies placed by an employment agency must be registered with TrustLine.

New York

New York City gives domestic workers, including nannies, full protection under the city’s Human Rights Law. According to the NYC Commission on Human Rights, families may run a limited background check covering references, education and criminal convictions. They may not ask about or consider arrests that did not lead to a conviction, youthful offender findings or sealed records. They also may not check credit history or ask about past salary.

Statewide, New York employers who use a background report must give the candidate a copy of Article 23-A of the Correction Law, which explains how criminal records can be considered. New York law also protects legal, off-duty cannabis use.

New Jersey

New Jersey’s Opportunity to Compete Act limits criminal history questions early in the hiring process. It covers employers with 15 or more employees, and domestic service workers are not counted toward that number. A typical family is not covered, but the law’s approach of waiting until after the first interview is still a good model. New Jersey also protects adults who use cannabis legally off the job.

Illinois

Illinois bars covered employers from asking about criminal history until a candidate is found qualified and selected for an interview or given a conditional offer. The law applies to private employers with 15 or more employees. Illinois also protects the off-duty use of lawful products, which includes cannabis for adults.

Washington

Washington’s Fair Chance Act is one of the few that applies to all employers, no matter how small, according to the Washington Attorney General. Amendments passed in 2025 tighten the rules, taking effect for larger employers in July 2026 and for smaller employers in January 2027. There is an important exception for families: the law does not restrict employers hiring someone who will or may have unsupervised access to children. Most nanny roles fit that description.

Washington also limits pre-employment drug tests for cannabis. Since January 1, 2024, most employers cannot reject an applicant based on lawful off-duty cannabis use or a pre-employment test that detects non-impairing cannabis traces.

Virginia

Virginia limits questions about certain past marijuana charges and convictions, and it protects workers who legally use medical cannabis. If you plan to include a drug test, ask your screening company how it handles cannabis results for Virginia candidates.

Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania’s fair chance rules for hiring apply to public jobs. However, a separate state law applies to all employers. It allows you to consider felony and misdemeanor convictions only to the extent they relate to the person’s suitability for the job. If your decision is based on a criminal record, you must tell the candidate in writing.

Texas

Texas has no fair chance law for private employers and no cannabis employment protections. Texas does limit how far back background check companies can report most convictions for jobs paying under $75,000 a year, usually seven years.

Florida, Georgia, Michigan, North Carolina and Ohio

These states have no statewide fair chance law for private employers. Where rules exist, they apply to government jobs. None of them has cannabis protections that would affect a family hiring a nanny. Families in these states still must follow every FCRA step described above.

Add-On Checks to Consider

A standard nanny background check focuses on identity and criminal history. Some families want to know more. Here is how the most common add-ons work, and when they make sense.

Nanny reading a book with a toddler on the couch during her first day of work
CheckWhat it looks atOffered by Sure Check?
Social media screeningPublic posts flagged for threats, violence, drug use, prejudice and other concernsYes, as an add-on
Civil records searchLawsuits where the candidate was suedYes, as an add-on (county or federal)
Credit checkDebts, payment history and credit accountsNo
Driving history (MVR)License status, suspensions, DUIs, violations and accidentsYes, as an add-on
Employment verificationPast employers, job titles, dates and reason for leavingYes, as an add-on
Reference checksFeedback from past families and employersYes, as an add-on
I-9 / E-VerifyWhether the nanny is eligible to work in the U.S.Yes, as an add-on

Social media screening

Many parents scroll through a candidate’s Instagram or Facebook on their own. That can backfire. A personal search can show you things the law says you should not consider, like a candidate’s religion, pregnancy, health, age or national origin. Once you have seen it, it is hard to prove it did not affect your decision.

A professional social media screening gives you a structured report instead. It lists the public profiles matched to the candidate, gives an overview of their online activity, and flags specific posts by category, such as threats, violence, drug and alcohol use, prejudice, profanity, weapons and self-harm. The categories that are flagged depend on your account settings. Because a screening company prepares the report, the same FCRA rules apply: written disclosure, signed authorization and the adverse action steps if you decide not to hire. Only public content is reviewed, and we never ask a candidate for passwords or friend requests.

Civil records

A civil search shows lawsuits rather than criminal cases. We report only cases where the candidate was sued and the case is still pending or was decided against them within the last seven years. The next section explains how civil searches work and why we never report cases the candidate filed.

Credit checks

Sure Check does not run credit checks for nanny hiring. A credit report says very little about whether someone will be a safe, caring nanny, and many places now limit how employers can use one. California, Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Nevada, Oregon, Vermont and Washington all restrict employment credit checks. New York State joined them in April 2026, and cities including New York City, Chicago and Philadelphia have their own limits.

If you want a sense of how a candidate handles responsibility, references from past families and a civil records search are usually more useful and carry less legal risk.

Driving history

If your nanny will drive your children to school, practices or playdates, add a driving history check. It shows whether their license is valid and lists suspensions, DUIs, moving violations and accidents. We report adverse driving records from the last seven years. Some states charge a small DMV fee, which we pass through at cost. It is also a good idea to confirm your car insurance covers the nanny as a driver.

Employment verification

An employment verification confirms that the jobs on a nanny’s resume are real. Our team contacts each past employer the candidate lists and confirms their position, dates of employment and reason for leaving. We reach out three times by phone and email over three business days.

Reference checks

References from past families are often the best preview of how a nanny will care for your children. If you do not have time to make the calls, our team contacts each reference the candidate lists and asks for comments on their work. It follows the same three-attempt process as employment verification.

I-9 and E-Verify

When you hire a nanny as a household employee, federal law requires you to confirm they are eligible to work in the U.S. using Form I-9. Sure Check’s I-9 and E-Verify option helps you complete this step. Unlike the background check, it happens once the nanny is hired, not before the offer, and it cannot be used to screen out candidates.

Should You Run a Civil Records Search on a Nanny?

A criminal background check shows criminal cases. A civil records search looks for something different: lawsuits between people or businesses, such as unpaid debts, contract disputes, landlord disputes and personal injury claims. Some families add a civil search to get a fuller picture of how a candidate handles money and responsibility.

Sure Check offers county civil searches and a nationwide federal civil search as add-ons to a nanny background check. They are not part of the standard nanny check, so ask for them when you order if you want them.

What a civil search reports

We report a civil case only when the nanny candidate is the defendant, meaning the person who was sued. We include the case only if it is still pending, or if it was resolved against the candidate within the last seven years. Cases older than seven years, and cases the candidate won or that were dismissed, do not appear.

How to use civil results

If a civil case does appear, treat it the same way you would a criminal record. Ask whether it relates to caring for children, how long ago it happened, and what the candidate has done since. A single unpaid medical bill or an old dispute with a landlord usually tells you very little. If you are leaning toward not hiring because of a civil record, follow the same pre-adverse and final adverse action steps described above.

What If a Nanny Enters Incorrect Information?

A background check is only as accurate as the name, date of birth and Social Security number the candidate enters. A typo or a false detail can send the search to the wrong person or miss records that belong to the right one.

How the check catches problems

Every Sure Check report starts with an SSN trace, which pulls the names and addresses tied to that number. We match records using name, date of birth, SSN and address history, so a mismatch, like an SSN linked to a different name, stands out.

Reduce fraud with ID verification

Add ID verification when you order. It checks the candidate’s government-issued ID, so the background check runs on the right person and it is much harder to use someone else’s information.

What to do if the information looks wrong

  • Compare the name and date of birth on the report with the candidate’s driver’s license or other photo ID.
  • If you find a simple typo, ask the candidate to correct it and run the check again.
  • If the candidate cannot explain a mismatch, or gives you details that do not match their ID, treat that as a serious warning sign.
  • If you decide not to hire because of something in the report, follow the pre-adverse and final adverse action steps described above.

Do I Need an EIN to Run a Background Check?

No. You do not need an Employer Identification Number (EIN) to run a nanny background check with Sure Check. Families can create an account with their own name and contact information and order a check the same day.

You can sign up for our $45 nanny background check here with no EIN, contract or monthly fee.

What you do need is the candidate’s written permission. The FCRA steps described above apply to you whether or not you have an EIN.

When you will need an EIN

An EIN matters for paying your nanny, not for screening them. In 2026, if you pay one household employee $3,000 or more in cash wages during the year, you owe Social Security and Medicare taxes on those wages. You report them on Schedule H with your personal tax return. You also owe federal unemployment tax if you pay $1,000 or more in cash wages in any calendar quarter.

Once either rule applies, you need an EIN to file Schedule H and give your nanny a W-2. You cannot use your Social Security number on these forms. You can apply for an EIN for free at IRS.gov in a few minutes. The IRS explains the full rules in Publication 926, the Household Employer’s Tax Guide.

A good order of operations is to run the background check first, then apply for your EIN and set up payroll once you have made your final hiring decision.

A Simple Compliance Checklist for Families

  • Make a written conditional offer before running the check.
  • Give a stand-alone written disclosure and get a signed authorization.
  • Use an FCRA-compliant background check company.
  • Do not let the candidate care for your children, even for a trial day, until the check has cleared.
  • Apply the same screening standards to every candidate.
  • Only consider records that relate to caring for children.
  • If something concerning appears, send a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and the Summary of Rights.
  • Wait about five business days and consider any explanation.
  • If you decide not to hire, send a final adverse action notice.
  • Check your state and city rules, especially in California, New York City and Washington.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is the right time to run a nanny background check?

Run it after you have chosen your top candidate and made a conditional job offer that they have accepted. This follows fair chance laws, saves money and respects the candidate’s privacy.

Should I run a background check before a working interview?

Run it after a conditional offer and before the working interview. A working interview means the candidate is caring for your child, so the check should clear first. Most checks come back within 8 hours, so you can make the offer, run the check and schedule the trial within a day or two.

How do I run a background check on a nanny I found on Facebook?

You do not need to send them to Care.com or another platform. Sign up for our $45 nanny background check, enter the candidate’s name and email, and we send them a secure invitation to complete the disclosure and authorization. You pay for the check, so the nanny does not have to create an account, pay a fee or wait for a profile to activate.

Do I need my nanny’s permission to run a background check?

Yes. Under the FCRA, you must give a written disclosure and get the candidate’s signed authorization before ordering a background check through a screening company.

What if a nanny refuses to consent?

You cannot run the check without consent. You can, however, decide not to move forward with a candidate who will not agree to a standard background check.

Do ban-the-box laws apply to families?

It depends on where you live. Many state laws only cover employers with 5 or 15 or more employees. Washington’s law covers all employers, though it has an exception for roles with unsupervised access to children, and New York City’s Human Rights Law covers domestic workers directly.

Can I drug test my nanny?

In most states, yes, with the nanny’s consent. In California, New York, New Jersey, Illinois, Virginia and Washington, cannabis rules may limit how you can use a positive cannabis result.

How far back does a nanny background check go?

It depends on the state. Several states, including California, New York, Texas and Washington, limit how far back most convictions can be reported, usually seven years. In other states, convictions can be reported regardless of age.

Is a free online search good enough?

No. Free people-search sites pull from databases that can be incomplete or out of date, and they do not follow FCRA rules for employment screening. An FCRA-compliant screening company searches court records directly and gives you the forms you need.

What happens if something shows up on the report?

Look at whether the record relates to caring for children, how long ago it happened, and what the person has done since. If you are leaning toward not hiring, follow the pre-adverse and final adverse action steps described above.

How Sure Check Helps Families Hire with Confidence

Sure Check Background Screening is an FCRA-compliant background check company that works with families, nanny agencies and care providers across the country. Our nanny background check includes an SSN trace, a nationwide criminal database search with the 50-state sex offender registry, and unlimited county criminal searches for every county tied to the candidate’s address history. Most checks come back within 8 hours, and our U.S.-based team handles the disclosure, authorization and adverse action notices for you.

Our nanny background check is $45, with any court or DMV fees passed through at cost. See everything included in the $45 nanny background check and sign up here.

Register for an account here and run your first nanny background check today.

About Sure Check

Sure Check Background Screening is a woman-owned, FCRA-compliant background check company built for the care industry. We help families, nanny agencies, childcare providers and home care companies hire safely, with fast results, simple pricing and a U.S.-based support team.

This article is for general information and is not legal advice. Laws change, and local rules may apply. Talk with an employment attorney about your specific situation.

Maggie Benson, founder of Sure Check Background Screening

Written by

Maggie Benson, Founder & President of Sure Check Background Screening

Maggie founded Sure Check to give care agencies, staffing firms and growing businesses fast, affordable and FCRA-compliant background screening with real, U.S.-based support. About Sure Check