Volunteer Background Checks: A Complete Guide for Nonprofits

Kids playing outdoors at a youth program run by screened staff and volunteers

Volunteers coach youth teams, deliver meals to seniors, mentor students, drive patients to appointments and handle donations. Many of them have the same access to vulnerable people that paid staff have, and sometimes more, because volunteers often work alone and with less supervision. A background check is one of the simplest ways to protect the people you serve, your volunteers and your organization.

This guide covers which volunteers to screen, what checks to run, how consent works, what it costs, and how to build a policy your board and your insurer will be comfortable with.

Which Volunteers Need a Background Check?

Screen based on what the volunteer will do, not just their title. Volunteers who should almost always be checked include those who:

  • Work with children or teens, such as coaches, mentors, tutors, camp volunteers and youth group leaders
  • Work with seniors or people with disabilities, such as companions, meal delivery drivers and respite volunteers
  • Drive on behalf of the organization
  • Handle money, donations or donor data
  • Enter people’s homes
  • Serve on the board or in leadership roles with financial authority

One-time event volunteers who are always supervised and never alone with vulnerable people may not need a check. Write down where you draw that line so it is applied the same way every time.

What Should a Volunteer Background Check Include?

A good volunteer package matches the risk of the role.

Basic package for most volunteers

  • SSN trace or identity verification
  • National criminal database search with county verification of any records found
  • National sex offender registry search

Enhanced package for volunteers working with children or vulnerable adults

  • Everything in the basic package
  • County criminal searches in every county where the person lived in the past seven years
  • State abuse and neglect registry searches where available
  • Reference checks

Add-ons by role

  • Motor vehicle record (MVR) for anyone who drives for the organization
  • Federal criminal search and a bankruptcies, liens and judgments search for treasurers and board members with financial authority
  • Fingerprint checks when state law requires them, such as for some youth programs

Do Volunteer Background Checks Require Consent?

Yes. When you use a screening company, the check is a consumer report. The Federal Trade Commission has said the Fair Credit Reporting Act’s employment rules can apply to volunteers, so treat volunteers the same way you treat job applicants:

  1. Give the volunteer a clear, stand-alone disclosure that a background check will be run.
  2. Get their written authorization.
  3. If the report leads you to turn someone away, send a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and a summary of their rights, wait a few business days, then send a final notice.

For volunteers under 18, get a parent or guardian to sign as well. Our guide to background checks on minors covers that process.

Can Nonprofits Get FBI Fingerprint Checks for Volunteers?

Sometimes. The federal National Child Protection Act and the Volunteers for Children Act let qualified organizations that serve children, the elderly or people with disabilities request fingerprint-based checks through their state. Each state runs its own program, with its own fees and approval process. Contact your state’s criminal records agency to see if your organization qualifies.

Fingerprint checks are useful, but they rely on arrest records that are not always updated with final court outcomes. Many organizations use both: the state fingerprint check where available, and a name-based check through a screening company for faster results and court-verified detail. Our article on fingerprint vs. name-based background checks explains the differences.

How Much Do Volunteer Background Checks Cost?

Volunteer packages are usually less expensive than full employment packages because they focus on criminal and registry searches. Costs rise with county court fees and add-ons like MVRs. Many organizations pay for checks out of their program budget. Some ask volunteers to pay a small fee, but that can discourage people from signing up, so think carefully before doing it.

Sure Check offers nonprofit pricing, and we partner with Volunteers Insurance Service (VIS) to make screening easier for organizations that insure their volunteers. You can see more on our nonprofits and volunteers page.

How Often Should You Rescreen Volunteers?

A background check only reflects records up to the day it runs. Long-term volunteers should be rescreened on a schedule. Common choices are every two or three years, or every year for volunteers who work alone with children. Continuous monitoring is another option that alerts you when a new record appears, without a full rescreen.

How to Write a Volunteer Screening Policy

A written policy keeps your process fair and consistent, and your insurer may ask for it. Include:

  • Which roles require which checks
  • When checks happen, such as after an application and before the first shift
  • Who reviews results and the standards they use
  • Which offenses disqualify a volunteer from which roles, and how you consider the age of the offense and evidence of rehabilitation
  • How you notify volunteers and handle disputes
  • How often you rescreen
  • How you store reports securely and who can see them

Pair the background check with other safeguards. Interviews, references, training on abuse prevention, two-adult rules and clear reporting procedures all matter as much as the check itself. The CDC’s child abuse prevention resources are a good starting point for youth-serving organizations.

What Happens If You Skip Screening?

When a volunteer harms someone, organizations are often sued for negligent selection or supervision. Courts ask whether the organization took reasonable steps to keep people safe. Skipping background checks for high-risk roles makes that case very hard to defend, and it can affect your insurance coverage, your funding and the trust of the families you serve. Our case study on the consequences of skipping background checks for nonprofits shows how this plays out.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do volunteers have to agree to a background check?

Yes. Volunteers must receive a written disclosure and give written authorization before a screening company runs a check.

What shows up on a volunteer background check?

Typically criminal convictions, pending cases and sex offender registry listings. Depending on the package, it can also include driving records, abuse registry results and identity information.

How long does a volunteer background check take?

Most volunteer checks through Sure Check are complete in one to two business days. Counties that require a court visit can take longer.

Can a nonprofit reject a volunteer because of a criminal record?

Yes, if the record relates to the role and you follow your written policy and the FCRA adverse action steps. Consider the type of offense, how long ago it happened and what the volunteer will be doing.

How often should volunteers be rescreened?

Every two to three years is common. Volunteers who work alone with children or vulnerable adults are often rescreened every year.

Who pays for volunteer background checks?

Most organizations pay for them. Some ask volunteers to cover a small fee, but this can reduce sign-ups.

Maggie Benson, founder of Sure Check Background Screening

Written by

Maggie Benson, Founder & President of Sure Check Background Screening

Maggie founded Sure Check to give care agencies, staffing firms and growing businesses fast, affordable and FCRA-compliant background screening with real, U.S.-based support. About Sure Check