Why Is New York So Expensive for Background Checks?

NYC background check
If you are an employer in New York City, you’ve may have noticed that criminal background checks can get expensive. Most counties in the U.S. do not charge at all for a criminal search, and a few hundred charge a few dollars. So why does New York cost so much more? This is because NY state uses background check fees to raise money for public defenders.  New York runs all of its criminal court record searches through the New York State Office of Court Administration, also called the OCA. Local courts used to handle these searches themselves. Starting in 2003, they were told to send everything to the OCA’s Criminal History Record Search unit in Manhattan. The five counties that make up New York City (Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and Staten Island) all go through this system. That means every NYC county search costs the same $95 as a full statewide search. The price wasn’t always this high. For years the search cost $65, which was already the most expensive court fee in the country. Then, in April 2019, state lawmakers added a $30 increase to the 2019-2020 state budget. Governor Andrew Cuomo signed the budget on April 12, 2019, and the new $95 fee started the next day, April 13. The state said the extra money would pay for lawyers for people who can’t afford one. A 2019 report from the New York City Comptroller found that courts across the state collected $195 million in criminal history search fees in a single year. All of $95 fee goes into the state’s Indigent Legal Services Fund, which helps counties provide attorneys to people who could not otherwise afford one.  Not everyone agreed with the increase. The background screening industry, including PBSA, pushed back against it. Some screening companies warned that a higher price might lead employers to skip the New York search and rely on cheap national databases. That would be a mistake. National databases often miss New York court records, and we’ve written about why relying on national background checks isn’t enough. There are a few things about the OCA search that employers should keep in mind. It only finds a match when the name and date of birth are exactly right, so one typo can cause a record to be missed. Each name searched is a separate $95 fee, which adds up fast if someone has a maiden name or other aliases. And if a record does come back, the OCA holds the whole request for a manual review, which can slow down your results. You can read more on the OCA’s FAQ page. Because the court collects its fee as soon as the search is submitted, it can’t be refunded once the order goes in. Our page on additional state and court fees explains how these charges work in other states, too. If you hire in New York City, you also need to follow the city’s Fair Chance Act. It says most employers have to wait until after making a conditional job offer before running a criminal background check. The NYC Commission on Human Rights explains the rules in detail. New York has also limited the use of credit checks in hiring, which we covered in New York Just Banned Credit Checks in Hiring. The $95 fee can feel steep, but it’s still the most reliable way to see a New York applicant’s criminal history. A bad hire costs far more than $95. If you have questions about screening candidates in New York, reach out to our team and we’ll walk you through it.
Maggie Benson, founder of Sure Check Background Screening

Written by

Maggie Benson, Founder & President of Sure Check Background Screening

Maggie founded Sure Check to give care agencies, staffing firms and growing businesses fast, affordable and FCRA-compliant background screening with real, U.S.-based support. About Sure Check

What Does the New York OCA Search Cover?

The Office of Court Administration’s Criminal History Record Search pulls from the court records of all 62 New York counties at once. For employers, that is the upside of the high price: one $95 search covers every county court in the state, including all five New York City boroughs. In most other states you would pay a separate fee or court researcher for each county.

A few points to know about the search:

  • The fee is charged per name. If a candidate has a maiden name or another alias, each name is a separate $95 search.
  • It reports court cases, not arrests. The OCA search shows criminal cases filed in New York courts. Arrests that never reached court will not appear.
  • Sealed cases are excluded. Cases sealed under New York law, including those sealed under the Clean Slate Act, are not released.
  • Possible matches slow things down. When a name and birth date return several possible matches, the OCA reviews them by hand before releasing results.

How the Clean Slate Act Changes New York Background Checks

New York’s Clean Slate Act took effect on November 16, 2024. It automatically seals many older convictions once the person has stayed out of trouble for a set time:

  • Misdemeanors are sealed three years after the person’s sentence, or release from incarceration
  • Most felonies are sealed eight years after release
  • Sex offenses and Class A felonies other than certain drug offenses are not eligible

The state has until November 2027 to finish sealing older records that qualify. As records are sealed, they drop out of the OCA search and cannot be reported or used in most hiring decisions. Some employers, such as schools, police agencies and employers that must fingerprint by law, can still see sealed records through official channels.

New York Hiring Laws That Affect Screening

The cost of the search is only one part of screening in New York. Employers also need to follow some of the strictest fair chance rules in the country.

  • Article 23-A of the Correction Law. Employers cannot deny a job because of a conviction unless there is a direct relationship between the offense and the job, or hiring the person would create an unreasonable risk. You must weigh eight factors, including the person’s age at the time, how long ago it happened and evidence of rehabilitation.
  • New York City Fair Chance Act. NYC employers cannot ask about criminal history until after a conditional offer. If you want to withdraw the offer, you must give the candidate a Fair Chance Notice and the report, and allow at least five business days to respond.
  • Credit check limits. New York City has limited credit checks for most jobs since 2015, and New York State passed its own ban in December 2025. See our article on New York’s credit check ban.

How to Keep New York Background Check Costs Under Control

  1. Use the OCA search only where it applies. Order it when the SSN trace shows a New York address in the past seven years, or when the candidate will work in New York and your policy requires it.
  2. Run the check after a conditional offer. This is required in NYC anyway, and it means you only pay the $95 for candidates you plan to hire.
  3. Collect all names up front. Ask for prior names on the authorization form so you do not have to reorder later.
  4. Do not substitute a national database. It looks cheaper, but database results still need to be confirmed at the court, and they miss many New York records.
  5. Use transparent pricing. Sure Check passes court fees through at cost and shows them on our fee schedule, so there are no surprise charges on your invoice.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a New York criminal background check cost?

The New York State Office of Court Administration charges $95 per name for its statewide criminal history search. Screening company service fees are added on top.

Why did New York raise the fee to $95?

The fee went from $65 to $95 in April 2019 as part of the state budget. The money goes to the Indigent Legal Services Fund, which pays for lawyers for people who cannot afford one.

Does the $95 New York search cover every county?

Yes. The OCA search covers court records from all 62 counties in New York State, including the five New York City boroughs.

Can I get a refund if the OCA search is canceled?

No. The court charges the fee as soon as the search is submitted, so it cannot be refunded once the order goes in.

How long does the New York OCA search take?

Many searches return within one to three business days. Searches with possible name matches go to a manual review and can take longer.

Do sealed records show up on New York background checks?

No. Records sealed by the court or under the Clean Slate Act are not released through the OCA search and should not appear on an employment background check.