Employers often ask us which background check is the “best” one: national, statewide or county. The honest answer is that each search covers different records, and relying on only one of them leaves gaps. A national database alone can miss recent cases. A statewide search alone misses everything outside that state. A county search alone misses the counties you did not search.
This guide explains what each search actually covers, where each one falls short, and how to combine them into a package that finds what matters without wasting money.
A Real-World Example of the Gap
In 2025, a former security guard in Pennsylvania was arrested after threatening violence at the Little League World Series. He texted his former supervisor a threat and posted a countdown on social media. Police charged him with eight felony counts of terroristic threats, and the case was filed in a local magisterial district court in Lycoming County.
Charges like these are filed in local court first. They show up in the county’s records right away, but they can take weeks or months to reach a national criminal database, if they reach it at all. An employer who ran only a national database search during that window could have seen a clean result. A county search in Lycoming County would have shown the case.
That timing problem is the main reason professional screening relies on county records.
What Is a County Criminal Search?
A county criminal search checks the court records in a specific county, either online through the court’s system or by a researcher at the courthouse. Most criminal cases in the U.S., including felonies and misdemeanors, are filed in county or local courts.
Strengths:
- The most current and complete source for criminal cases
- Shows case details such as charge, disposition, sentence and dates
- Results are verified directly at the source
Limits:
- Only covers the county you search
- Some courts charge fees, and a few take longer when records must be pulled by hand
To decide which counties to search, screening companies use an SSN trace, which lists addresses tied to the person’s Social Security number. A standard package searches every county where the person lived in the past seven years.
What Is a Statewide Criminal Search?
A statewide search checks a central repository run by the state, usually the state court administrator or the state police. Some states, such as New York, Pennsylvania and Colorado, have strong statewide court systems that cover every county. Others have repositories that are missing records from smaller counties or only include cases reported by law enforcement.
Strengths:
- Covers many counties at once in states with complete systems
- Useful when an applicant has lived in many counties in one state
Limits:
- Quality varies a lot from state to state
- Some states only include records with fingerprints, so misdemeanors may be missing
- Misses everything outside that state
We often call a state-only check a hidden mistake. An applicant who moved from Ohio to Colorado last year could have a clean Colorado statewide result and a recent conviction back in Ohio.
What Is a National Criminal Database Search?
A national criminal database is a private collection of records gathered from courts, corrections departments, sex offender registries and other sources across the country. It is not the FBI database. Private employers cannot run FBI checks except in specific situations allowed by law.
Strengths:
- Casts a wide net and can find records in counties the SSN trace did not show
- Low cost and fast
Limits:
- Coverage is uneven, and some counties and states report little or nothing
- Records can be months out of date
- Results often lack full details, such as the final disposition
Because of these limits, the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires screening companies to make sure the information they report is accurate and up to date. Good providers treat a database hit as a lead and confirm it at the county court before it appears on your report.
What About Federal Criminal Searches?
Federal crimes, such as mail fraud, tax evasion, drug trafficking across state lines and many financial crimes, are tried in U.S. District Courts. These cases do not appear in county or state searches. A federal criminal search checks the federal court system through PACER records by district. It is worth adding for finance, management and executive roles.
How Do Cost and Speed Compare?
Each type of search has a different price and turnaround, which is why employers are sometimes tempted to cut corners.
- National database searches are the cheapest and usually return within minutes. The low price is why some online services sell them as a complete “background check.”
- County searches cost more because each one is a separate search, and some courts add their own fee. Most return within one business day, though courts that require a clerk or researcher to pull files by hand can take several days.
- Statewide searches range from a few dollars to $95 or more, depending on the state. New York’s statewide court search, for example, costs $95 per name. Speed depends on the state system.
- Federal searches are moderately priced and usually return within one to two business days.
The cost of a complete, layered package is small compared to the cost of a bad hire, a negligent hiring claim, or an FCRA lawsuit over an inaccurate report. Sure Check publishes court fees on our fee schedule and passes them through at cost, so you can see exactly what each search adds before you order.
Which Search Matters Most for Your Industry?
Some roles need extra layers. Child care, senior care and health care employers in many states must add a fingerprint check through a state agency. Transportation employers need motor vehicle records and DOT-specific checks. Financial roles benefit most from federal criminal and civil searches. If you hire across several of these areas, set up separate packages by role so each hire gets the right searches and no more.
How Should You Combine These Searches?
Most employers get the best coverage with a layered package:
- SSN trace to find where the person has lived
- National criminal database to find leads in places the trace missed
- County criminal searches in every county from the past seven years, plus any county where the database found a possible record
- National sex offender registry search
- Statewide or federal searches when the role or state calls for them
This approach catches recent cases, finds records in unexpected places, and verifies everything at the source. It is the setup we recommend for most clients, and you can see how it is priced on our criminal background checks page.
What About Records That Appear After You Hire?
The Little League case also shows a second gap: the person had already been hired. A background check is a snapshot of one day. New charges filed after that day will not show up unless you check again. Sure Check’s continuous monitoring watches for new records and alerts you, so you are not relying on a check from years ago.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a national background check enough?
No. National databases are helpful for finding leads, but they miss records and can be out of date. Any record found should be confirmed at the county court, and county searches should be run where the person lived.
What is the difference between a county and a statewide background check?
A county search checks one county’s court records directly. A statewide search checks a state repository that may cover all counties or only some, depending on the state.
Do national background checks include the FBI database?
No. Private national criminal databases are separate from the FBI’s records. FBI fingerprint checks are only available to employers when a law requires or allows them, such as for child care or health care roles in many states.
How many counties should a background check search?
Most packages search every county where the person lived in the past seven years, based on the SSN trace. Some employers also search the county where the person works.
Why do some county searches take longer?
Some courts do not offer online access, so a court researcher has to visit in person or a clerk has to pull the file. Possible name matches also take extra time to confirm.
Do I need a federal criminal search?
It is a good idea for roles involving money, management or sensitive data, since federal crimes like fraud and embezzlement do not show up in county or state searches.
Hiring in another state? See our state guides for Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Illinois and Texas background checks.

Written by
Maggie Benson, Founder & President of Sure Check Background Screening
Maggie founded Sure Check to give care agencies, staffing firms and growing businesses fast, affordable and FCRA-compliant background screening with real, U.S.-based support. About Sure Check
Related reading
- How to Hire When a Background Check Shows a Record
- How Criminal Record-Keeping Works in the U.S. (and Why It’s So Complicated)
Ready to screen your next hire? Learn more about our criminal background checks, or create your Sure Check account to get started.
